I don't follow college baseball very closely, so my opinion comes with a ton of caveats. When Warde hired Tracy Smith, many were surprised because he was out of baseball for a year after a failed run at Arizona State.
To be fair to the process, coaching baseball at a northern school is not the idea position for a hot coaching prospect. You want to be at a place that can play and practice year round. It's the reason
Clemson doubled the salary of Erik Bakich. Baseball at Michigan is nowhere funded like the football or basketball programs. I still don't understand why NCAA Baseball is not played more in the summer then the spring? Having a snow out, is not a good thing in a baseball season. This can make recruiting a challenge.
Warde also got turned down quickly by Michigan's top coaching prospects. So he was looking at guys like the CMU coach and Tracy who was clearly available. Tracy had a nice run at IU, which made him a hot candidate for a baseball school. ASU picked him up quickly hoping he would carry them back to the top of college baseball. That didn't happen and after 6 years and with 2 years left on his contract, ASU let him go.
Tracy did recruit well to ASU but that talent didn't translate to post season wins and there were rumors of locker room issues which made the Sun Devils make a move. When you recruit MLB talent, there can be plenty of egos in the dugout.
So lets try to answer the Risky or Safe question:
Risk:
- He is 56
- Fired a year ago for lack of post season wins and locker room issues
- Michigan's current roster has been decimated with the loss of Coach Bakich
- Was probably on the bottom of the candidate list
- Built a strong Big Ten program at IU
- Has a ton of college baseball experience
- Michigan probably didn't over pay
- Known to be a good recruiter

